American Modern Insurance Group
KPMGJan 2022 - Oct 2023

American Modern

Role

Lead Product Designer

Team

  • 1 Lead Product Manager
  • 1 Lead Product Designer
  • 2 Engineering Leads

Platforms

  • Web App
  • Responsive Web

American Modern Insurance Group (AMIG) specializes in niche insurance products — from boats and collector cars to mobile homes and pets. As a B2B-focused company, AMIG relies heavily on agents to sell policies and provide servicing. While this model supported business growth, it created friction for policyholders, who found themselves overly dependent on agents for even basic tasks.

Problem Statement

AMIG's policyholders were capable, digitally-savvy adults being treated like they needed a middleman for everything. How might we give them the self-service tools they were already asking for — reducing agent dependency without undermining the relationships agents had built?

Impact

1.7Million

Policyholders

1.9billion

Premium Volume

Background

American Modern is a leading specialty insurance provider operating in a B2B model.

American Modern logo

American Modern

Network of Agents

Network of Agents

Policyholders

Policyholders

They offer niche insurance products such as:

Boat Insurance

Mobile home insurance

Collector Car Insurance

Pet Insurance

Because AMIG operates through agents. Agents serve as the primary information channel and Policyholders rely heavily on agents for servicing.

Old Digital Storefront experience
Old Digital Shopfloor experience

Existing Painpoints

Because AMIG operates through agents, agents serve as the primary information channel and therefore policyholders rely heavily on agents for servicing.

This model can lead to serious friction.

What We Heard From Policyholders

“Everything requires an Agent.
I wish I could manage my policies myself.”

“My policies are difficult to understand.”

“My claim is taking forever to be paid out. What is the hold up?”

The Result:

High call volumes to Customer Support teams

Confusion driven by legacy terminology and regulatory language

Frustration around transparency

Policyholders appreciated agent expertise—but were craving autonomy.

Program Objective

Alleviate CSR call volume by providing Policyholders with the answers and empower them to self-service.

Project Objective

Deliver Digital Storefront & Shopfloor experiences for Policyholders.

Digital Storefront

Policyholder's first impressions of American Modern. How they enter the experience and start to “browse” pre-login.

Marketing-Oriented

Digital Shopfloor

To allow American Modern customers to meaningfully engage with their policies (access documents, make payments, file claims)

Service-Oriented

Approach

1

Immerse ourselves in AMIG's wealth of research

We leveraged AMIG's existing research and translated findings into realized insights via:

Data-driven personas

User journeys

Jobs-to-be-done

Epics and prioritized features

This ensured our designs were grounded in real customer needs—not assumptions.

Data-driven personas
2

Ideate & Play

We leveraged AMIG's existing research and translated findings into realized insights via:

Data-driven personas

User journeys

Jobs-to-be-done

Epics and prioritized features

This ensured our designs were grounded in real customer needs—not assumptions.

Site map
3

Definition & Hand-Off

Pushing our explorations into tangible high fidelity designs.

UI Templates

Documented Figma Design Library

End-to-end interactive prototypes

Design-ready assets for engineerings

Digital Storefront

We redesigned the entry experience to:

Create stronger brand engagement before login

Clarify product categories

Simplify specialty insurance explanations

Reduce jargon

Improve product discoverability

This reframed American Modern from "agent-dependent insurer" to "accessible specialty provider".

Digital Shopfloor

We created a structured self-service dashboard that allowed users to:

View all active policies in one place

Access documents without agent mediation

Track claim status with transparency

Understand payment schedules and history

See clear explanations of coverage

Information architecture was simplified to reduce cognitive load and eliminate industry-heavy terminology where possible.

More Features

Marketing components

Design Handoff

KPMG's scope was design and delivery; implementation was handled by AMIG's internal engineering teams and the redesigned client portal is live today.

While our engagement concluded at design delivery, the foundation we established enabled:

Improved Digital Clarity
Expanded Self-Service Capabilities
Reduced Reliance on CSR call centers
A scalable UI framework for future enhancements